Once again, psychologys membership-based grassroots advocacy network showed itself to be a powerful force when mobilized. With literally tens of thousands of psychologists letting their senators know what they thought of the Health Insurance Marketplace Modernization and Affordability Act, or HIMMA, the ill-conceived health insurance deregulation bill was stopped in Congress this spring.
On its face, HIMMA proposed to enable small businesses to band together for the purpose of offering health insurance coverage to employees who have not otherwise been able to get coverage from their employers. Although a laudable goal, the legislation proposed to accomplish this end by preempting or eliminating a generations worth of state-level protections for mental health and other health-care services. As many as 68 million people in state regulated health plansand millions more with individual insurance coveragewere faced with the potential loss of mental health coverage if the bill became law. Thirty-nine state mental health parity laws and 32 state-mandated minimum mental health benefit laws would be preempted. So, too, would 43 freedom of choice laws, which guarantee a consumers right to choose a psychologists services when their health plan covers a psychiatrists services.
One of the APA Practice Organizations top legislative priorities for 2006 has been to stop HIMMA, designated as S.1955. The 600-plus attendees at this years State Leadership Conference were thoroughly briefed on the legislation, including the most important arguments to make when they visited their members of Congress at the close of the conference. Psychology delegates visited 86 Senate offices to express their opposition to HIMMA. And numerous additional face-to-face
conversations between psychologists and Senate staffers occurred
between the conference and the eventual demise of S.1955.
But more than just constituent visits are
necessary to successfully oppose legislation that was supported
by the insurance industry and the business community. With the
use of the Legislative Action Center at www.APApractice.org
throughout the spring, psychologists sent more than 18,000
e-mail messages concerning HIMMA to elected officials. Reports
of Senate offices being inundated with anti-HIMMA
calls in the days just before the Senate vote were also not
uncommon.
To buttress psychologys grassroots
response, APA Practice Organization government relations staff
sought support from state attorneys general and state insurance
commissioners, two groups assumed to have concerns about
eliminating state insurance regulations. By the time S.1955
came to the Senate floor for a vote, 41 state attorneys general had a signed letter from the National
Association of Attorneys General to the Senate objecting to HIMMA.
Twenty insurance commissioners also wrote in opposition to the
legislation.
Other groups besides psychology were
concerned about the detrimental effects of HIMMA were it to
become law, and Practice Organization staff co-chaired the Stop
HIMMA Coalition to convene the largest possible community to
work the agenda. The coalition included the AARP, Families
USA, AFL-CIO, American Academy of Pediatrics, American Nurses
Association, American Podiatric Medical Association, American
Cancer Society and American Diabetes Association. Even with all
of these groups coming together to oppose HIMMA, the opposition
was still considered by many to be a David pitted
against the Goliath of the National Association
of Manufacturers, the National Association of Realtors, the
U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Federation of
Independent Business. Rarely has this set of special interests
been stopped in the current Congress.
When the Stop HIMMA Coalition hosted two
national call-in days, more than 21,000
individuals used the toll-free phone number provided to express
their opposition to HIMMA to their members of Congress. In
addition, one coalition member, the American Chiropractic
Association, reported that its members in Wisconsin alone made
45,000 contacts with Senators offices. The
coalitions members also worked to take its messages
about HIMMA public through orchestrated media
coverage. Among other efforts, APA, the American Diabetes
Association and the National Partnership for Women and Families
created an audio news release (ANR) distributed to radio
stations. Over 4,000 radio stations aired the ANR, reaching
close to 6 million listeners nationwide.
Psychologys grassroots capability
has been building for close to 20 years. While it is not
realistic to expect that we can win every legislative battle we
fight, it is clear that our members, through grassroots
activity, are a force to be reckoned with.
It also is clear that winning the battle
isnt the same as winning the war. HIMMA continues to
have strong support on Capitol Hill, and the bills
proponents may try to resurrect it or similar legislation in
the coming months. If that happens, we know we can marshal our
grassroots psychologists yet again to help protect the
interests of tens of millions of Americans and the health
benefits they need.