In my last column, I
addressed the issue of how much the public was being exposed to
psychologists and psychological content in the media. Using a
variety of data sources, I estimated that such exposure was
substantial. But of course, exposure to psychology
doesn't tell us anything about the public's
understanding or attitudes about the field. In his review of
public attitudes about psychology in the American Psychologist,
Benjamin (1986, 41, 941946) noted that "it
was doubtful that the public ever had a reasonable
understanding of the nature of the field."
During the mid-1990s, APA commissioned two
national telephone surveys that, among other things, explored
the public's attitudes and knowledge about psychology and
psychologists as health providers. One survey, conducted by
Porter/Novelli, was a national random sample of 1,200 adults
ages 21 to 65 years who were the primary health-care
decision-makers for the family. The second survey, conducted by
Penn-Schoen Associates, was of a national random sample of
1,087 adults 18 years old and over. The surveys addressed a
number of questions including the public's understanding
of what psychologists do and how psychologists are trained, and
broader questions about their attitudes about mental health
treatment.
What do we do? In the Penn-Schoen
survey, participants were asked the open-ended question,
"What do psychologists do?" After coding the
responses, it was found that 45 percent believed that
psychologist helped people with their problems or provided
counseling. Approximately 30 percent believed that we studied
human behavior or analyzed people. Another 6 percent felt that
we talked and listened to people.
Where do we work? In another open-ended question in which multiple
responses were possible, over 80 percent of respondents said that
psychologists "usually work"in private practice, 60
percent mentioned community clinics, and 50 percent mentioned
hospitals. Only 5 percent mentioned schools or universities.
How are psychologists trained? About
33 percent said that a doctoral degree was required, although
31 percent said a master's degree was required.
Interestingly (or regrettably), 17 percent said only a
bachelor's degree was required, and 15 percent said a
medial degree is the minimum educational requirement.
Seeking mental health assistance. A
related but somewhat different question concerns the nature of
the public's attitude toward mental illness and the
receptivity of the public to mental health care. The good news
is that people say that they are open to consulting with a
mental health professional for a variety of problems. A
majority reported that they were very likely or somewhat likely to seek
mental health assistance for problems such as a serious mental
illness (93 percent), suicidal feelings (87 percent), drug or
alcohol problems (86 percent), eating disorder (83 percent),
depression or anxiety (80 percent), children's problems (76
percent), coping with a chronic illness (66 percent), marital
problems (62 percent), and child rearing issues (60 percent). Only
54 percent reported that they would seek assistance for stress or
healthy lifestyle issues, and only 31 percent reported that they
would seek such assistance for work-related problems.
Who can treat mental health problems? Compared
with psychiatrists and social workers, the majority of
respondents believed psychologists were viewed as the
professionals "most likely" to treat problems such
as stress, marital difficulties, children's problems, a
death in the family, coping with a serious illness or problems
at work. Psychiatrists were viewed as most likely to handle
problems such as serious mental illness, suicidal feelings and
depression or anxiety.
Barriers to treatment. Despite the
respondents' openness to mental health treatment, they
did perceive a number of barriers that they considered
"very or somewhat important" to receiving such
treatment. These included, among other things, lack of
insurance coverage (mentioned by 84 percent), concerns about
costs (84 percent), lack of confidence in outcome (76 percent),
lack of knowledge about how to find the right professional for
their needs (68 percent) and not knowing if it's really
appropriate to seek help (66 percent).
Overall, based on the information in this
and in my previous column, when it comes to the public's
view of psychology and mental health issues, there is both good
news and bad news. Although our presence in the media is
strong, we don't have a good idea about the quality or
accuracy of the information being provided. It also appears
that the public does not have a broad view of what
psychologists do, especially as scientists. The good news is
that the public seems very willing to seek mental health care,
which has not always been the case. Yet, significant barriers
exist for them to gain access to this care. Clearly, we have
much work to do to ensure that the public understands who we
are and what we do. Our public education goals must include
reducing the barriers to mental health care and expanding the
public's understanding of psychologists' many work
settingsfrom the laboratory to schools, to corporate
suites and government.