February 23, 2006
Americans Engage in Unhealthy Behaviors to Manage Stress
New survey findings show gender differences connections between stress and unhealthy choices affect mind/body health
NEW YORK – Americans engage in unhealthy behaviors such as comfort eating, poor diet choices, smoking and inactivity to help deal with stress, according to a new national survey released today. People experiencing stress are more likely to report hypertension, anxiety or depression and obesity. In particular, women report feeling the effects of stress on their physical health more than men. The survey results seem to tie in with what research shows, that 43 percent of all adults suffer adverse health effects from stress. Given the potential health complications related to stress, it is fair to say stress certainly is a health problem in America.
The survey, conducted by the American Psychological Association (APA) in partnership with the National Women’s Health Resource Center and iVillage.com, looked at how people deal with stress and its effect on mind/body health among women and men.
Comfort Eating and Poor Diet Choices
According to the survey findings, one in four Americans turns to food to help alleviate stress or deal with problems. Comfort eaters report higher levels of stress than average and exhibit higher levels of all the most common symptoms of stress, including fatigue, lack of energy, nervousness, irritability, and trouble sleeping. Comfort eaters are also more likely than the average American to experience health problems like hypertension and high cholesterol. In addition, 65 percent of comfort eaters characterize themselves as somewhat or extremely overweight and are twice as likely as the average American to be diagnosed with obesity.
Stress levels are higher for frequent fast-food eaters. While only 13 percent of people who did not eat at a fast food restaurant in the last week are very concerned about stress, this number rises to 21 percent of among those who ate fast food meals in the past week.
31 percent of women say they are comfort eaters versus 19 percent of men.
Men are more likely than women to opt for unhealthy snacks such as potato chips.
Smoking and Inactivity
People who are “very concerned” about their stress are more likely to be smokers. A quarter (27 percent) of those very concerned about their stress smoke every day, versus 19 percent of those “not at all” concerned with stress. Interestingly, forty-nine percent of single fathers and 31 percent of single mothers smoke three or more times a week. Americans who report they are “very concerned” about stress also exercise less. Roughly a third (36 percent) said they did not exercise in the last week, versus a quarter (27 percent) of those “not at all concerned” about stress.
“People who cope with long-term stress by engaging in unhealthy behaviors and lifestyle, may very well alleviate symptoms of stress in the short term, but end up creating significant health problems in the long run,” says Russ Newman, PhD, JD, executive director for professional practice, APA.
Women and Men Experience Stress Differently
Forty-seven percent of Americans say they are concerned about stress. Nearly half of Americans, especially women, parents, and people of working age, are concerned with the amount of stress in their lives. Women say stress affects them more than men do (51 percent versus 43 percent) and are more likely than men to report more things that stress them out. Women also express concern about how stress affects their lives more than men. Women dealing with stress report feelings of nervousness, wanting to cry, or lack of energy, while men talk about trouble sleeping or feeling irritable or angry. Women are more likely than men to report health problems related to stress such as hypertension, anxiety or depression and obesity.
Stress is higher among the family’s health care decision maker. Seventy-three percent of women identify themselves as the primary decision maker in the household for health issues versus 40 percent of men.
“As the health managers of their families, women disproportionately feel the effects of stress. From taking care of children to serving as the caregivers for elderly parents, the survey found that women report more stressors and greater concern for the effects that stress has on their daily lives, said Elizabeth Battaglino Cahill, executive director of the National Women’s Health Resource Center. “Unfortunately, women are not taking the necessary steps to alleviate stress and their physical health is suffering.”
Kellie Gould, Editor-in-Chief of iVillage.com said, “Consistent with the survey findings, we hear from the women who visit our site that they are under a great deal of stress and shoulder the majority of responsibility for caretaking and for being the “COO” of their household. While women may be more vocal about the stress in their lives, we feel it is important for them to understand and appropriately improve upon how they manage it.”
Stress Affects Mind/Body Health
Stress affects overall mind/body health. Adults who experience a great deal of stress rate their mental and physical health lower than adults who are not experiencing stress. People experiencing stress are more likely to report a number of specific ailments and symptoms.
59 percent report feeling nervous or sad
51 percent report symptoms of fatigue
56 percent report inability to sleep or sleeping too much
55 percent report lack of interest, motivation or energy
46 percent report headaches
48 percent report muscular tension
32 percent report frequent upset stomach or indigestion
37 percent report change in appetite
29 percent report feeling faint or dizzy
26 percent report tightness in chest
23 percent report change in sex drive
What’s Stressing Us Out
We have many sources of stress in our lives; stress is generally driven by work and money followed by health concerns and children.
Leading Sources of Stress
59 percent say money
59 percent say work
53 percent say health problems affecting parents or other family members
50 percent say health concerns
50 percent say nightly news or state of the world today
48 percent say health of immediate family (spouse, partner or children)
41 percent say children
Twenty-eight percent of women call money a “very significant” source of stress, versus 19 percent of men. Twenty-seven percent of women worry about the health of a spouse or child, versus 20 percent of men, and 27 percent worry about health problems affecting parents, versus 20 percent of men. Twenty-four percent of women say children are a very significant source of stress in their lives, compared to 15 percent of men.
“Everybody experiences stress,” says Newman. “The key is how effectively people deal with and manage stress. People who turn to comfort food or smoking are starting a vicious cycle. Their attempts to reduce stress can actually lead to health problems that result in increased stress."
This random-digit-dial telephone survey was designed and administered by Greenberg Quinlan Rosner. The survey reached 2,152 adults, 18 years or older. The base sample of 1,600 was supplemented with an over sample of 552 African Americans and Hispanics. The data were weighted by gender, age, race, income, education, marital status, and region to ensure an accurate reflection of the population. The sample size with these weights applied is 1,600. The survey was conducted January 12-24, 2006 and carries a margin of error of +/- 2.1 percentage points.
The American Psychological Association (APA), in Washington, DC, is the largest scientific and professional organization representing psychology in the United States and is the world's largest association of psychologists. APA's membership includes more than 150,000 researchers, educators, clinicians, consultants and students. Through its divisions in 53 subfields of psychology and affiliations with 60 state, territorial and Canadian provincial associations, APA works to advance psychology as a science, as a profession and as a means of promoting health, education and human welfare.
The National Women’s Health Resource Center (NWHRC) is the leading independent health information source for women. The non-profit organization develops and distributes up-to-date and objective women’s health information based on the latest advances in medical research and practice. NWHRC believes all women should have access to the most trusted and reliable health information. Informed women are healthier women.
iVillage is “the Internet for women” and consists of several online and offline media-based properties that seek to enrich the lives of women, teenage girls and parents through the offering of unique content, community applications, tools and interactive features. The iVillage Network was the number one “women’s community site” on the Web and reaches more than 11percent of women 18+ online in the U.S. (comScore MediaMetrix, January 2006). iVillage Inc. (NASDAQ: IVIL) was established in 1995 and is headquartered in New York City.