|
Report on Children, Youth, and Family Policy Initiatives
June 23, 2003
Public Interest Policy staff of APA's Public Policy Office (PPO)
are actively engaged in many legislative and federal activities to promote the
welfare of children, youth, and families in Congress and with the Bush
administration. PPO staff continue to interact on a regular basis with members
of Congress, their staff, and federal agency officials, both in coalitions with
other organizations and independently. PPO activities include the preparation of
legislative background materials, statutory provisions, and formal comments on
proposed legislation and regulation, as well as mobilizing the APA membership
for grassroots advocacy efforts. PPO staff also identify and invite
psychologists to testify at congressional hearings and APA congressional
briefings, as well as to represent the association on federal agency advisory
councils and at executive branch meetings and White House conferences.
This document provides an overview of PPO activities undertaken from January
1- June 23 of this year to help ensure that children, youth, and families
receive full attention at the federal level. Additionally, PPO's Public Interest
Policy staff administer the APA Congressional Fellowship Program, through which
four psychologists are currently spending a year on the staff of a member of
Congress and/or congressional committee. The office also offers a yearlong
public policy internship program for psychology graduate students.
Child, Youth, and Family Appropriations
On March 25, PPO staff submitted report language to the Senate
Appropriations Committee in support of FY 2004 funding for critical programs at
the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the Administration for
Children and Families, the Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative
Services, and the Indian Health Service, among others. (An overview of the
funding status for key federal programs for FY 2003 and 2004 can be found on the
PPO Web site -- see address at the end of this document.)
Head Start Program
To bring psychological research to bear in the Head Start
reauthorization process, PPO cosponsored a congressional briefing on June 6,
"The Head Start Advantage," with the Society for Research in Child
Development and the National Association for the Education of Young Children.
The panel included Larry Aber, Ph.D. (Columbia University), Alshadye Yemane
(Head Start graduate, now with The Urban Institute), Cybele Raver, Ph.D.
(University of Chicago), Diane Slaughter-Defoe, Ph.D. (University of
Pennsylvania), and Hiro Yoshikawa, Ph.D. (New York University). The presenters
provided a strong research basis for retaining federal control of the program
with its multiple components and performance standards.
On June 19, a bill to reauthorize the Head Start program, the
"School Readiness Act of 2003" (H.R. 2210), was approved by the House
Committee on Education and the Workforce. The legislation, which passed along
party lines, refocuses the program's broad mission on early literacy skills and
establishes a block grant program in eight states. The bill does not include the
controversial proposal to transfer Head Start from the Department of Health and
Human Services to the Department of Education.
[Back to top]
Special Education for Children with
Disabilities
On February 6, senior staff from PPO and the four APA
Directorates, along with a former member of the APA Committee on Psychological
Tests and Assessment, met with Robert Pasternack, Ph.D., Deputy Assistant
Secretary for the Office of Special Education Programs, to discuss the pending
Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) reauthorization. Other topics
included the dissemination of evidence based practices, teacher training,
discipline, and gaps in the current research literature.
On April 10, PPO staff submitted IDEA report language to the
House Education and the Workforce Committee promoting the value of cognitive
testing and teaching preparation and training, and raising concerns about
proposed disciplinary procedures for special education students. PPO staff
provided related guidance to the offices of Reps. George Miller (D-CA), ranking
member on the committee, Denise Majette (D-GA), and Charles Rangel (D-NY)
regarding these issues. PPO had earlier spearheaded an inter-directorate effort
that culminated in the development of a statement by the APA Committee on
Psychological Tests and Assessment concerning cognitive testing in IDEA, in
response to the 2002 report of the President's Commission on Excellence in
Special Education. The Board of Directors approved this statement to serve as
the basis for PPO briefing materials.
On April 30, PPO joined other health and mental health
organizations in opposing two last-minute floor amendments offered to the House
IDEA reauthorization bill, the "Improving Education Results for Children
with Disabilities Act of 2003" (H.R. 1350). The amendment offered by Rep.
Thomas Tancredo (R-CO), which would have redefined "specific learning
disability" as "due to a medically detectable and diagnosable
physiological condition relying on physical and scientific evidence," was
defeated. Unfortunately, the amendment offered by Rep. John Shadegg (R-AZ),
which expresses the non-binding Sense of Congress that only "a physician or
other person certified by a State health board" can diagnose disabilities
for special education placement, was approved. (Rep. Shadegg's office apparently
was unaware that this provision would not include psychologists in many states).
PPO is now directing its attention to the Senate to ensure that these amendments
receive no further support. It should be noted that the House-passed bill
includes a number of provisions proposed by APA to enhance prevention/early
intervention, research, and related services personnel activities.
On June 18, PPO and Practice Directorate staff attended two
coalition meetings with staff of the Senate Committee on Health, Education,
Labor and Pensions (HELP) to discuss the Senate IDEA reauthorization
legislation, the "Individuals with Disabilities Education Improvement Act
of 2003" (S. 1248). Attention focused primarily on lauding the behavioral
assessment and intervention components, while expressing concern about the
disciplinary provisions and the possible incorporation of the House-passed
children and medications provision (see next section). As follow-up, an
inter-directorate APA briefing paper was circulated to all members of the Senate
HELP Committee on June 23 with a cover letter highlighting positive features of
the legislation and offering several recommendations for further improvement.
School Policy and Procedures Concerning
Medication
On May 14, PPO sent an APA letter to Rep. John Boehner (R-OH),
Chair of the House Education and the Workforce Committee, in opposition to the
"Child Medication Safety Act of 2003" (H.R. 1170). This Act threatens
state educational agencies with the loss of federal funding unless the state
develops policies and procedures prohibiting school personnel from requiring a
child to obtain a prescription for medication (in the form of a controlled
substance) as a condition for attending school or receiving services. Copies of
this letter were sent to the full committee in preparation for a hearing on
children and medication, which PPO staff attended. The substance of the Act had
earlier been included in the House-passed version of the IDEA reauthorization
bill. H.R.1170 passed the House on May 21 with a favorable amendment by Rep.
Patrick Kennedy (D-RI) safeguarding communication between school personnel and
parents regarding a child's school performance and behavior. PPO staff continue
to closely monitor this legislation.
[Back to top]
Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment
On May 22, a House-Senate conference committee approved
legislation (H.R. 14/S. 342) to reauthorize the 1996 Child Abuse Prevention and
Treatment Act (P.L. 104-235). On June 19, it was cleared for President Bush's
signature. The bill includes language contributed by PPO to provide for full
physical and mental health screenings for children in child protective service
custody and for longitudinal research, among other provisions.
Access to Children's Health Insurance
Sponsored by Senators Edward Kennedy (D-MA) and Charles Grassley
(R-IA), the "Family Opportunity Act" (S. 622) would allow
middle-income families of children with disabilities to "buy into" the
Medicaid program to obtain health and mental health services. PPO staff, in
coalition with the Consortium for Citizens with Disabilities (CCD), continue to
conduct Hill visits and send letters to urge key members of Congress to support
the bill.
Child and Adolescent Mental Health
Training
PPO Public Interest and Education Policy staff worked with Rep.
Patrick Kennedy's (D-RI) office last year in drafting a child mental health
training initiative. Rep. Kennedy re-introduced the bill this Congress on March
19 as the "Child Healthcare Crisis Relief Act" (H.R. 1359). A
companion bill was introduced on June 10 by Senators Susan Collins (R-ME), Jeff
Bingaman (D-NM), and Christopher Dodd (D-CT). The legislation includes PPO
suggestions regarding definitions of providers and interagency collaboration. A
Public Policy Advocacy Network (PPAN) Action Alert to increase the number of
congressional cosponsors was sent to key network members and to 17 relevant APA
divisions. PPO also sent letters of support to the four congressional sponsors
noted above and looks forward to thanking Rep. Kennedy in person at an upcoming
meeting with new APA CEO Norman Anderson, Ph.D.
[Back to top]
Adolescents and Trauma
On June 11, PPO arranged for APA to cosponsor a congressional
briefing with the College Board on "How Traumatic Events Worldwide are
Affecting Adolescents' Decisions about Postsecondary Education." Michael
Cohen, Ph.D., a developmental psychologist and member of New York City's crisis
response team, presented information regarding the critical link between
children's mental health and educational achievement. He cited findings from his
study of New York City children's psychological reactions to traumatic events,
particularly the terrorist acts of September 11th. Dr. Cohen
conducted a pre-briefing telephone interview with Metro Network (listening base
of close to five million).
Children and Media
PPO and Children Now led a successful coalition effort to lobby the Federal
Communication Commission (FCC) to safeguard the interests of children in the
recent regulatory action to loosen the rules on corporate media consolidation in
local markets. In a 3-2 party-line vote, the FCC inserted provisions to insure
that companies adhere to the educational television obligations under the
Children's Television Act (CTA). Station owners cannot rerun educational
programming across their stations and have it count towards the CTA requirement.
Children are the only group that had protections inserted into the final
rulemaking. As part of a diverse coalition of public health, education and child
advocacy groups, APA staff had sent a formal letter in January to FCC Chairman
Michael Powell (along with formal comments to the proposed rule), requesting an
exploration of how the potential rulemaking would affect children and
minorities. As follow-up, PPO staff met with all of the FCC Commissioners later
that month to advocate for further consideration of children's issues in the
debate over the proposed rulemaking.
On a related front, PPO submitted comments to the FCC on April 24 as part of
the children's media policy coalition concerning children's programming (both
educational and informational) on public interest obligations for digital
television.
Welfare Reform
PPO staff sent a PPAN Action Alert on February 10 to relevant
APA divisions and governance groups asking members to call their U.S.
Representative to urge him/her to vote against H.R. 4, the welfare reform
reauthorizationbill introduced by Rep. Deborah Pryce (R-OH) and 12 others, since
it did not provide for mental health assessment and treatment, among other
limitations. Unfortunately, the bill passed the House on February 14 by a margin
of 230-192. There has been no further action yet in the Senate.
President's New Freedom Commission on Mental
Health
PPO and Government Relations Office (GRO) staff represented APA
at the monthly meetings of the President's New Freedom Commission on Mental
Health. (The final public meeting was held in March.) PPO staff continue to
support the efforts of our three APA members, Deanna Yates, Ph.D. (President,
Texas Psychological Association), Stephen Mayberg, Ph.D. (Director, California
Department of Mental Health), and Larke Huang, Ph.D. (Director of
Research/Senior Policy Associate at Georgetown University's Center for Child
Health and Mental Health Policy). Dr. Huang co-chairs the Children and Families
Subcommittee of the commission. PPO and GRO staff also met with commission
chair, Michael Hogan, and executive director, Claire Heffernan, together with
APA executive staff on April 16 and as part of a newly formed Campaign for
Mental Health Reform on May 30 to discuss the final report to the President and
next steps. The commission is expected to release its final report by the end of
June (two months past due), in keeping with its mandate to conduct a one-year
study of the nation's mental health service delivery system and make
recommendations for improvement.
On April 24, PPO staff presented a public comment on behalf of
APA at the SAMHSA National Advisory Council meeting. The statement highlighted
the windows of opportunity offered by the upcoming report of the President's New
Freedom Commission on Mental Health and the pending SAMHSA reauthorization
process. It also stressed the need to focus on prevention (particularly of
suicide), workforce training, and the mental health needs of special
populations, including minorities, people with disabilities or chronic illness,
and gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender persons.
APA Congressional Fellowship Program
The APA Congressional Fellowship Program, now in its 28th year,
places psychologists in congressional offices for one year as part of the larger
American Association for the Advancement of Science policy fellowship program.
The 2002-2003 APA Congressional Fellows are: Catherine Cozzarelli, Ph.D., who is
working with Senator Jeff Bingaman (D-NM), Linda Demaine, J.D., Ph.D., who is
working for the Senate Judiciary Committee Democratic staff (ranking member
Patrick Leahy (D-VT)), Neil Kirschner, Ph.D., who is working with Representative
Pete Stark (D-CA), ranking Democrat on the House Ways and Means Subcommittee on
Health, and Mischa Thompson, Ph.D., who is working for Representative Charles
Rangel (D-NY), ranking Democrat on the House Ways and Means Committee.
[Back to top]
Back to Top^
|