Kim Mills: A fake toll notice, an email that looks like it came from your bank, a call from a voice that sounds like your child pleading for money—in recent years, scams have become increasingly difficult to recognize and increasingly costly. Nearly 4 in 10 American adults say they’ve been victims of fraud, and in 2025 alone, Americans lost nearly $21 billion to cyber-enabled crime, about $4 billion more than the year before.
Scammers have long exploited fundamental aspects of human psychology: Our instinct to trust and the way we make decisions under pressure. Now, new technologies, including artificial intelligence, are making it easier than ever to create convincing scams. Meanwhile, the consequences of fraud can go far beyond financial loss, leaving victims struggling with shame, depression, and anxiety.
So how is technology driving the recent increase in scams, and are there other factors at play as well? How do scammers manipulate our thinking and behavior? Who is most at risk? And what can we do to protect ourselves—and each other—from fraud? Welcome to Speaking of Psychology, the flagship podcast of the American Psychological Association that examines the links between psychological science and everyday life. I’m Kim Mills.
My guest today is Dr. Stacey Wood, a professor of psychology at Scripps College, where she leads the Neuropsychology of Decision-making Lab. Much of her research has focused on why people are susceptible to scams and fraud, and she recently coauthored a journal article called “The Scammer’s Psychological Warfare: A Call to Arms.” She also writes the Psychology Today blog The Fraud Crisis, and in addition to her research, Dr. Wood consults as an expert witness on legal cases involving fraud.
Dr. Wood, thank you for joining me today.
Stacey Wood, PhD: Very happy to be here, Kim.
Mills: So just a moment ago, I mentioned that fraud is getting worse. It’s becoming more prevalent and more sophisticated. Why is that? What’s happened in the last few years?
Wood: Well, I think the obvious explanation is related to technology. So social media, smartphones were on the scene since about 2010, but really became extremely popular in about 2015 when roughly half the world’s population started using these devices, and it just made targeting individuals anywhere all the time so much easier.
Mills: In a recent journal article, you and your coauthors described scammers’ tactics as psychological warfare. What did you mean by that? What psychological tendencies do they exploit?
Wood: I often say that they are better psychologists than I am. There’s a number of them, but they are just adept at identifying blind spots humans have. So one very common tactic is to understand—humans when they’re in a state of emotional distress are just not at their best in terms of their thinking. The goal is to get you on your worst day at the worst time of that day. Now, how do they know when that is? They don’t, so they’re just targeting you all the time. So that one tactic is just that excessive volume of approaches. Another tactic is once they have located people that maybe are in a state of crisis, they introduce a crisis and then they introduce a solution and then they monitor you. They keep you on that phone, they keep texting you to make sure you comply. So it’s really quite devious.
Mills: Why do even intelligent, savvy people get sucked into these scams?
Wood: I can share, I recently consulted on a case where a retired physician truly believes Elon Musk is in communication with him. And when you’re on this side of that, it just seems unbelievable, right? We’re at the end point though. We’re talking to him and he’s saying something that’s probably not true, but what we don’t understand is all of the micro steps that occurred to hook this person and keep him in this narrative of false belief.
Sometimes there’s a cognitive component. There are scams that are targeting very elderly people or those with mild cognitive impairment and they’re very effective. But oftentimes it’s more social psychology. So having a high IQ or going to med school doesn’t necessarily spare you from these psychological vulnerabilities that are targeted. In his case, being a physician is a huge part of one’s identity. So retirement, losing that status, having less income, less validation, it just created a vulnerability that opened the door for scammers to exploit.
Mills: I’m just curious about this case in particular. I mean, was Elon Musk asking him for money? Why would Elon Musk need to reach out to some doctor?
Wood: Right. On its face, it makes no sense, but it started as an investment opportunity related to Elon Musk, and actually there’s been IPOs in the news. So it’s not necessarily—So that initial step is in line with current events, that there’s investment opportunities. And then after the fake investment opportunity in one of Elon Musk’s companies, keeping him on the hook by saying even Elon Musk is impressed with you and et cetera, it doesn’t seem as farfetched to the victim. And remember, it’s meeting these status needs, that he’s an important person. And also, I have to say the scam is seamless. It’s frictionless the way they’re asking for money on a smartphone, through an app. The family’s at wit’s end.
Mills: Now you’ve written about various types of scams in your Psychology Today blog, fake toll notices, political fundraising scams, and even, as you just said, a scheme involving a medical professional. Can you give us a sense of the range of fraud schemes that people are encountering today? I mean, how are these cons evolving to keep tricking us?
Wood: Yeah, I’m going to give you a few categories of what I’m seeing as really common scams and also that end up costing people a lot of money and grief. One of the worst ones out there is a scam that the criminals call “pig butchering.” That’s their name. Those of us that work on this call them transnational financial crimes, and they involve a long con that starts as an approach in a very innocuous way, usually on Indeed or similar work site. So not necessarily an email for an investment fraud right away. Sometimes it’s romantic, sometimes not, they develop a relationship, then start saying, My cousin’s been making a lot of money doing this thing and I’m going to try it, showing screenshots of all the money they’re making, always in crypto, saying they’ll coach the person, demonstrating some early wins again on a site that looks just like Coinbase or similar.
The mimics are very, very good. And 6 months later when the person’s all in, the scammer disappears and that’s when the criminals call it, it’s time to butcher the pig. And again, it goes on and on. So people, especially I think younger people who are more comfortable with these online relationships where they may not meet a person in real life for some time, the first 6 weeks may not seem unusual at all. So that’s a terrible one.
Imposter scams are very common right now. So I’m calling you from the IRS, I’m calling you from the FBI, I’m calling you from ICE. There’s been a lot of scams targeting individuals who are immigrants, legal immigrants, claiming that there’s some problem with their visa. That’s incredibly scary. And again, very sophisticated people have been like, What do I pay to make this go away? I meant to fill out that form. That’s something that’s happening in California right now, probably elsewhere.
Romance scams, you think, Don’t we all know by now? But they’re actually increasing. Again, I’m seeing the midlife and later life scams. That’s kind of the population I work with though, so I don’t know if they’re increasing with younger people. And then tech scams. So those are an older scam, but they just keep resurfacing and it’s this, You may have a virus, click on this link. And the scammers can actually take over the individual’s computer and access private information, ultimately draining bank accounts. Then they feign, they go, Well, you need to bring in the FBI. And then it’s like, of course, a fake FBI. Yeah, they’re really awful. Yeah.
Mills: So we’ve moved well beyond the Nigerian prince emails.
Wood: Yeah. One theory about those emails is they were really just designed to catch the most gullible. The scammers didn’t want the person that was just curious about it. They wanted people that were missing red flags. So it was more of a feature than a bug to use an obvious scam. But these newer ones, they are mimicking legitimate websites and organizations extremely well.
Mills: Well, let’s talk for a couple of minutes about the toll that fraud takes on the victims of these scams. I mean, you’ve interviewed many people who have been duped in your work, and what are these conversations, what have they told you about what happens to people psychologically when they’ve been scammed?
Wood: Yeah, I’m glad you brought this up because I feel like it’s been gotten less attention and it’s truly devastating. So let’s take a hypothetical victim of pig butchering. They’ve been spending 6 months in this relationship sending money, and maybe probably their family starts at a certain point saying, Hey, what are you doing? You’ve never met this person. And the scams create a wedge between the victim and their family. Or the Elon Musk case, the family’s help—so when it all crashes, they’re often very isolated and then they’re ashamed and humiliated because maybe family members were saying, I’m worried if this person isn’t real, and they get kind of entrenched. So they’re isolated, they’re humiliated, they feel betrayed. Some are angry, many are depressed. I see some trauma symptoms like blaming oneself, believing the world isn’t a safe place anymore, problems with sleep, just still so much self-blame and lack of confidence, focusing on themselves.
Mills: Yeah. How could I have been so stupid?
Wood: Yeah. And there’s been some other research in psychology that the period after being scammed, these individuals are at super high risk for being revictimized.
Mills: I’ve heard that younger people are less ashamed of admitting that they’ve fallen victims to one of these scams. Why is that? And are people generally getting more comfortable talking about how they got duped at least to help other people not fall into the same trap?
Wood: Yeah, I agree. I think there’s research showing in terms of reporting, younger people are more likely to report they’ve been scammed to authorities. One thought about that is that for older adults, acknowledging the scam may trigger certain stereotypes about aging, like, oh, the old fool, or I’m starting to lose it. And so fear about that, about complying with some stereotype we associate with aging, even in these incredibly high functioning people, fear about losing autonomy. So the family’s going to step in now as a power of attorney because dad lost most of his retirement money and he can’t really afford to lose any more. And older people lose more money too, have more money, but they’re targeted so much more. So that’s my sense is that acknowledging being scammed may have these other psychological effects in older people. To the second point you made, I do hope the narrative is changing, that we just view scam victims as crime victims, which is what they are, and less about some personal failure.
Mills: If somebody put a gun to your ribs when you were out walking at night and took your money, you would be okay with telling people about that.
Wood: Right, or someone broke into your house.
Mills: Yeah. How much is our own use of artificial intelligence making us more susceptible to scams? I mean, is there information that we shouldn’t be putting into AI chats?
Wood: I don’t know the answer to that in terms of a study. My instinct is absolutely there’s information we shouldn’t be putting into it, but it’s incredibly intimate information that AI is gleaning from us, particularly if it’s not on a private setting. I do know that the criminals are using AI. So when they’re just targeting you to chitchat on Indeed or Discord, which is used by younger people, they often just use bots to do the initial groundwork of developing a relationship and finding out information about people. So they’re using it and people don’t know. They’re engaging with what will be a bot that’s gathering very detailed information about you to target you, very detailed, your social group, your hobbies. When I was talking about the pig butchering, it’s not just, Oh, I saw you on Indeed. It’s like, Oh, I saw that you used to work at Goldman Sachs in the New York office. I was there too. Did you know this manager? Yeah, you probably know this other person. When I’m in LA, I’m wondering if you want to get together. We’re starting this new group. And so it’s that detailed.
Mills: But I mean, how do you not put this information out if you have say a LinkedIn profile and everybody can see that you worked in these five places in the last 10 years?
Wood: Yeah, right. And it’s a helpful tool for professional networking. But I don’t think most people are aware that scammers have moved from more social media type—Instagram to more like Indeed. I mean, they’re on Instagram too, but if I got a notification from a potential contact in Indeed and their overall bio looks like a good fit, I’d probably just connect.
Mills: So it’s hard to know what you’re watching out for these days.
Wood: Yeah, exactly. I mean, the ask is the red flag. Asking for money.
Mills: Are there factors that put people at a special risk for becoming a fraud victim? And you said that the field has focused a lot on older adults, but that’s been changing, hasn’t it? Are there other groups that are at risk as well?
Wood: Yeah. I mean, it’s sort of everyone’s at risk, but if it’s a certain day and again, there was a scam targeting psychologists, there was a scam targeting physicians, there’s a scam targeting legal immigrants. So it’s more like there are bespoke scams that are designed to target a certain affinity group. And so it’s hard to protect yourself from those kind of scams.
Having said that, we do know there’s some kind of general factors that increase your risks. So even very, very mild cognitive decline, there’s a huge increased risk in scam susceptibility. Another one is if you have a major transition, divorce, death, retirement, empty nest, job relocation, for the next 2 years, there’s evidence that individuals—from the FTC—are at increased risk for scams. Another one is depression, right? So depressed individuals are at greatly increased risk for scams and fraud.
Mills: Because why? Because somebody is reaching out and that makes them feel better?
Wood: Yeah, no, that’s what I mean. That’s what’s interesting about it because I think of my depressed clients as sort of withdrawing and having less energy. So I think it’s partly cognitive concentration. They’re getting hammered with the same phishing and other scam attempts, and they’re more vulnerable and less able to fend them off. So yeah, I don’t know that we know exactly why, but I do know that that’s across different data sets, different research groups, depression is a risk factor.
Mills: At the individual level, how can we protect ourselves from fraud? I mean, are there habits or strategies that can help us resist this manipulation? Should we all be surfing the internet incognito? Does everybody need a VPN? I mean, what is going to save us?
Wood: Yeah, I should be doing those things myself, but I don’t. Those are helpful steps. I think monitoring your bank account, a lot of scams aren’t necessarily psychological vulnerability. They’re just taking your money or ID theft or phishing. So all of those, it’s probably going to happen and just monitoring your accounts and making sure you have fraud alerts, all of that is helpful. In terms of these, like the pig butchering or the imposter or the romance scam, the best intervention is a third party. Someone to say, Kim, take a breath. Hold on. You always pay your taxes on time. The IRS doesn’t really call people. Let’s figure this out. Let’s take a step back. And so maybe that’s why depressed lonely people don’t necessarily have that third party that they can use as a sounding board because the best scams, they get you enmeshed quickly and then they leverage you once they have some of your money or kind of in the game and other psychological mechanisms kick in to keep you engaged.
I know that’s depressing, but I think overconfidence is a risk. So believing you’re going to be able to discern credible from not credible people approaching you. So yeah, I think I’ve just become very skeptical.
Mills: So clearly there’s a limit to what we can do individually. I mean, asking a third party for input is a good idea, but what should we be doing as a society to combat this fraud? I mean, what responsibilities do banks, technology companies, governments have to protect us from this?
Wood: Yeah, I think it’s more of a structural challenge right now. I totally agree. Yeah, they’ve surpassed human cognitive resources in terms of social engineering of the scam. So they’ve figured us out.
I don’t want to pick on any particular company, but banks, they do have algorithms that help detect suspicious transactions, but I think those could be improved and that’s definitely an important line of defense. And one suggestion some of us make is on your accounts to have a trusted other. So they can’t act or see your account, but that when the bank sends a warning to you, it also is sent to your trusted other to give them a heads-up. Brokerage firms already are able to do it. Banks, I don’t know if they’re allowed because of confidentiality issues, but that’s something people have tried.
In Minnesota, they did pass a law that they could put holds on suspicious transactions. I think it was, I might get it wrong, but it was like 2 weeks or something. It’s either 14 or 21 days. So when you see a person who’s had no transactions above $5,000 and then sent $100,000 to Thailand, the banks there are able to legally put a hold on the account. And in many states, they’re not allowed to do it. It’s a person’s money. They’re not necessarily allowed to do that. So that’s an experiment that is playing out. Marti DeLiema, a researcher there has been studying it and she says on the one hand it’s helpful, but on the other hand, the individuals that it’s happened to can be very upset because whether it’s a scam or not, they believe it was real and they believe it’s their money.
Something else that’s being done more in the U.K., I’d like to see it here, is that the platforms are being held accountable. So you click on a link on Instagram, you end up losing $100,000. That platform has no liability in the U.S. And so Meta, Google—again, I’m not picking, it’s on all of them—could be doing more, I believe, to be identifying these criminal actors and taking down their sites. They have AI, but they are also paying money. So I mean, I can share that I’ve been targeted and nearly scammed recently. I mean, I was trying to rebook a flight, and I’m not going to say the airline, but they often have a long wait time, and I noticed they got through right away. I was like, Oh, it’s my lucky day. But it was actually a scam site that came up first in Google that looked quite like the airline.
And until they told me the rebooking fee was like $800 and it’s an airline where the rebooking fee’s usually $75, I’m like, Wait a second. Again, you know how the sponsored ads come up first. So I would like to see that being addressed more at that level, that there’d be some liability for the platforms that are hosting criminal activity.
Mills: Now, when you see something like that as a consumer, I mean, should you be reporting that to who? The Federal Trade Commission, somebody else? What do you do?
Wood: I know I didn’t, but that’s true. That would’ve been a good thing to do.
Mills: And what about as far as the federal government goes? I mean, are they doing anything? Are you aware of anything in the works? Is the FBI on this?
Wood: The FBI and even the Secret Service and the Postal Inspector’s Office are involved in individual scam cases. And I’ve worked with the postal inspectors on a number of cases related to when it’s coming to the mail, like a lottery scam or a sweepstake scam. We did just have a summit, an elder justice summit at the Department of Justice that I attended trying to help prosecutors both at the AG level and also the state level have better tools for prosecuting cases involving scams. But again, that’s at the individual level. So I’m not sure what is happening at a federal level in terms of addressing this problem.
Mills: Well, just to wrap up, what do you see coming down the pike and what are you working on now? What are the big questions you’re still trying to answer?
Wood: Something that’s been of interest to me are the cases like the Elon Musk case that I started with, in terms of the development of that extreme belief. And I’ve been interested in looking at other populations where ultimately individuals develop extreme beliefs like in conspiracy theories or these individuals that believe the sovereign citizens, they don’t have to pay taxes and they face federal prison. They really become entrenched in this belief. And I’ve been very interested in how that process works, how narratives are reinforced, how you take someone that does not have a psychological disorder and essentially create one. So in my lab, we were looking at a scale that’s been used to identify deviations from rationality that increase risk for conspiracy theory and using it with scam victims and people at risk for scams to see if there’s parallels. And it seems like there is. Yeah.
Mills: Well, this is all very interesting and helpful. I hope that we’re raising some awareness out there. I want to thank you for joining me today, Dr. Wood.
Wood: Yeah, it’s been a pleasure. Thanks for taking on this topic.
Mills: You can read more about Dr. Wood’s work and the work other psychologists are doing to combat fraud in the October issue of APA’s magazine Monitor on Psychology. Go to www.apa.org/monitor. You can find previous episodes of Speaking of Psychology on our website at speakingofpsychology.org or on Apple, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts. And if you like what you've heard, please subscribe and leave a review. If you have comments or ideas for future episodes, you can email us at speakingofpsychology@apa.org Speaking of Psychology is produced by Lea Winerman.
Thank you for listening. For the American Psychological Association, I’m Kim Mills.