Social expectations and other factors bias eyewitness identification
Seeing the same person in multiple lineups increases the likelihood an eyewitness will identify that person as the culprit, even if the person is innocent, a phenomenon called the repeated-suspect effect. Research in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied shows how factors related to memory and social expectations may shape this effect, potentially increasing the risk of misidentification. In one experiment with 316 university students, participants who saw a biased lineup (in which the innocent suspect stood out) showed a stronger repeated-suspect effect than those who saw a fair lineup (in which all lineup members looked similar). Another experiment with 303 university students highlighted the role of social expectations: Participants were more likely to report feeling influenced by the researcher’s presence when they saw multiple lineups or when they saw a biased lineup.
DOI: 10.1037/xap0000553


