The Change Healthcare data breach in February 2024 highlighted the importance of good cyber hygiene when data from more than 190 million patients was stolen after hackers gained unauthorized access to the company’s data through a portal that did not have multifactor authentication enabled. Change, which serves as a middleman between providers’ electronic health records and health insurance plans, processes billions of claim submissions, provider payments, and other information each year. After the hack, for weeks many psychologists did not receive payments from insurance companies and they struggled to pay employees, rent, and other expenses. Practice owners often shielded their staff and patients from this financial instability, which meant they were bearing significant levels of stress as they waited for a resolution.
While the Change ransomware attack affected a wide range of medical and behavioral providers, one of the most notable data breaches targeting mental health clinicians made headlines in 2020 when someone hacked more than 30,000 patient records at Vastaamo, a psychotherapy provider with 20 clinics and 400 employees in Finland. The hacker sought ransom from patients for highly sensitive information, and these people became vulnerable to identity theft.
Learning about cybersecurity can feel overwhelming, but approaching this ongoing defense in small, manageable steps can reduce your risk of a nerve-racking data breach. “The first step is to get the blinders off that this will not happen to your practice,” said Alexandra J. S. Fouracres, CPsychol, a psychologist and a cybersecurity consultant. Getting started is “easier than you think,” she said. She encourages therapists to begin by evaluating their defenses and pinpointing their weaknesses. “Most people know what they are if they start thinking about it,” she said.
For example, if your passwords are stored on a document on your device, an alternative is to get a protected digital password manager to safely store usernames and passwords, and use different, strong passwords. Practitioners should also consider scheduling regular reminders to review which files they can delete because storing them longer than needed increases risk. State retention periods can vary, so it is wise to check state requirements for how long files must be stored.
Up-to-date security software for your computer is another important layer of protection, and “if you have used the same product for years, it might be time to switch,” Fouracres said. When researching computer software security products, ensure they have real-time ransomware protection, and use the trial period to confirm you are comfortable using it. Once the software is installed, complete updates whenever they are available because these have been implemented to provide increased coverage and fill any weaknesses in the product.
Therapists who offer telehealth visits should select a HIPAA-compliant platform that includes end-to-end encryption and multifactor authentication, said Allison Funicelli, assistant vice president of the risk management group at AWAC Services Company, a member company of Allied World (Allied World is the insurance carrier for the American Professional Agency, which provides professional liability insurance to APA members). Be sure the vendor’s platform provides a business associate agreement, which is designed to ensure the vendor complies with HIPAA standards to protect the patients’ personal health information.
It’s also critical to consider cybersecurity when using AI in a clinical setting. Funicelli encourages clinicians to make sure their AI platform is HIPAA-compliant and find out how frequently the data—such as patient notes from a recorded session—is purged. The individual provider should be the only person who can access the sensitive information, she said. The AI-generated recording of the session should be purged as soon as a transcript of the recording is created and downloaded, preferably within 24–48 hours after the session. It is important for an office practice or organization to create standard policies and procedures related to the use of AI in compliance with state and federal guidelines, Funicelli said. To help practitioners safely integrate these tools into their practices, APA also recently published the Ethical Guidance for AI in the Professional Practice of Health Service Psychology. Funicelli also recommends ensuring data is backed up regularly. Practitioners who are using a third-party platform should learn how often and where the data is backed up.
An additional layer of protection is having cyberinsurance, which costs around $40 per month and covers expenses related to data compromise from a cyberattack, cyber extortion, misdirected payment fraud, and more. Take time to read the terms and conditions of the policy, which often require practitioners to maintain certain security standards. This could include requirements related to firewalls, software updates, and how often data is deleted. The policy outlines what is covered, and knowledgeable insurance brokers can explain the terms and conditions.
Fouracres also recommends drafting a detailed plan for what to do and how to recover from a cyberattack, with such details as how to get your devices offline quickly, who to contact from the cyberinsurance team, how to report the attack to authorities, and how to communicate about the breach with patients. Recovery should also include removing any potential malware, accessing backup files with important information, and improving cybersecurity to prevent future attacks. “The more layers you have, the better your chances are of stopping someone,” she said.